Websites
Sell online without Shopify or Etsy taking a cut
How to sell online without Shopify fees or a marketplace commission, what still costs money on your own shop, and when staying on Etsy is the smarter move.
Ben Harvie8 min read
If you sell something you make or stock, you have probably wondered whether you could sell online without Shopify fees, Etsy fees or an eBay cut taking a slice of every order. You can. It is not free, and it is not right for everyone, so this post gives you the honest version: what you stop paying, what you keep paying, and when you should leave things exactly as they are.
I am Ben, I build websites for small businesses in Edinburgh and the Lothians, and I will tell you at the start that the answer for a lot of people is "stay where you are for now". Let me show you how to work that out.
What a marketplace actually takes from each sale
A marketplace is a website that gathers lots of sellers in one place and brings buyers to them. Etsy and eBay are the best known. In return for the buyers, they take money from you in more than one way, and the ways add up.
Taking Etsy as the example, one UK guide to its fees, from an accounting software firm (linked in the next paragraph), lists a small fee for each listing, a percentage of the sale price as a transaction fee, and a separate payment processing fee on top, which is the charge for moving the customer's card payment to you. It also notes that the percentage is charged on the postage you list as well as the item. Those figures change from time to time, so check the seller's own fees page before you rely on any number, mine included. The point is the shape of it: several charges, on every order, for as long as you sell there.
You can read that guide to Etsy fees for UK sellers and work out your own total on a typical order. Add up what you paid in a normal month, then multiply by twelve. That yearly number is what you are comparing against the cost of running a shop of your own.
Shopify works differently. It is a service that lets you build your own shop, but you rent it by the month, pay a processing fee on cards, and can pay more again for add-ons. So it is a step towards owning your shop, not the whole way. You are still renting the shop window.
What owning your own shop means
A shop of your own is a part of your own website. Your products, your basket and your checkout sit on your own web address. There is no marketplace in the middle, so nobody takes a commission on the sale, nobody shows your customer a rival's product beside yours, and nobody can change the rules or close your account without warning.
The customer is also yours. When someone buys on a marketplace, the marketplace holds the relationship, and you may see only limited details about them. On your own shop you can see who bought, thank them properly and tell them when something new comes in, provided you handle their details lawfully (more on that below).
That is the real prize, more than the fee saving. A marketplace sends you shoppers while you pay, and they stop the day you stop paying or the day the marketplace decides to show somebody else first. A shop of your own builds something you keep.
What still costs money on your own shop
This is the part that gets skipped in the sales pitch, so here it is plainly. Selling on your own site is cheaper per order in most cases, but it is not free.
- Card payments. Someone has to move the money from the customer's card to your bank, and that company charges a fee on each payment. You pay it on a marketplace too. It does not go away.
- Your web address. The name of your site, such as yourbusiness.co.uk, is rented yearly.
- Hosting. That is the computer where your site lives so people can visit it at any hour. It has a running cost.
- The padlock in the address bar. That is the certificate that shows customers the connection is private. It is usually bundled in with hosting now, but it is a real thing somebody has to keep renewed.
- Your time. Photographing, describing, packing and posting are all yours either way. A marketplace does not do them for you.
What you stop paying is the percentage on every sale and the listing charges. For a business that sells a lot, that can be a large saving. For a business that sells a little, it can be smaller than the running costs of the shop, which brings me to the honest bit.
When a marketplace is the right call
Here is the unwelcome part. If you have no customers yet, a marketplace may be better than a shop of your own.
The reason is simple. A marketplace comes with shoppers already in the building. People go to Etsy or eBay to buy things, and you can appear in front of them on day one. A new shop of your own is an empty street. Nobody knows it exists, and you have to bring every visitor yourself, through Google, social media, markets, word of mouth or something else.
So I would leave things alone if any of these is true:
- You sell a few items a month and the fees you pay are small.
- Almost all your buyers find you through the marketplace and you have no other way of reaching them.
- You have no time to bring people to a shop of your own, and no wish to learn how.
- Selling is a hobby that pays for itself, not a business you are growing.
None of that is a failure. It is the right tool for that stage. The people I would nudge towards their own shop are the ones who already have regular customers, a following or repeat buyers, and who are paying the marketplace for sales they would have made anyway.
A sensible way to move without losing sales
If you decide to own your shop, you do not have to leap in one go. The safe route is to run both for a while.
Keep your marketplace listings. Open your own shop beside them, with the same products, and put a card in every parcel that says where to buy direct next time. Tell your existing customers by message or at the market stall. Over a few months you will see how many orders come to the new shop, and you can drop the marketplace products that are least worth the fees.
Two things to get right as you do. First, UK rules on marketing say you need a person's permission before you email them promotional material, with a limited exception for existing customers, so an order is not the same as agreement to a newsletter. The Information Commissioner's Office sets this out on its website, and your shop should have an unticked box rather than a pre-ticked one. Second, do not promise customers anything about delivery or returns on your site that you will not honour.
If you want to see what a site build costs in general terms, my post on how much a small business website costs in Scotland goes through it, and the cost of running a shop is a topic for the free consultation, because it depends on what you sell.
Frequently asked
Can I sell online without Shopify fees? Yes, by having a shop built as part of your own website rather than renting one from a platform. You still pay the card payment fee, your web address and hosting, but you do not pay a monthly platform rental or a commission to a marketplace.
Is it cheaper to sell on my own website than on Etsy? Often, once you sell enough, because a marketplace takes a share of every sale and a shop of your own does not. If you sell very little, the running costs of your own shop can outweigh the saving, so work out your yearly fees on the marketplace before you decide.
Do I still pay card fees if I have my own online shop? Yes. Whoever moves a customer's card payment to your bank charges a fee on each order, whether you sell on a marketplace or on your own site. What goes away is the extra commission on top.
Will I get fewer sales if I leave Etsy or eBay? You may, at least at first, because those sites bring shoppers to you and a new shop of your own does not. That is why I suggest running both for a while and moving the products that sell best through your own regulars first.
What waiting costs, and what I do about it
If you do nothing, the fees keep coming off every order, and the customers who buy from you stay the marketplace's customers rather than yours. Competitors who build their own shop keep that margin and that list of buyers, and they can spend it on better photographs, faster postage or a lower price. Over a few years that gap grows, and it grows quietly.
What I do about it is practical. I look at what you sell and how you sell it now, tell you honestly whether your own shop would pay for itself, and say so if it would not. If it would, I build the shop as part of a site that is fast on a phone, easy to buy from and written about your business, with your web address, hosting and padlock set up for you. That is my Website creation or redesign service, and an online shop of your own with no platform commission is part of it.
If you are weighing this up, book the free consultation (opens in a new tab) and bring your last few months of marketplace fees. I will tell you straight whether a shop of your own is worth building yet, and you can leave with a clear answer whichever way it goes. I will also tell you what to do first if the answer is "not yet", and nobody will pressure you either way.


